skip to main content
How to Pick an Accountant

In today's complex financial landscape, having the right accounting professional by your side can make the difference between simply staying afloat and achieving true financial success.

1. Understanding Different Types of Accounting Professionals

Before diving into the selection process, it's important to understand the different types of accounting professionals available:

Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) 

CPAs have completed extensive education requirements, passed a rigorous examination, and maintain ongoing education requirements. They can perform all accounting functions, represent clients before the IRS, and provide additional services like financial planning and business consulting.

Enrolled Agents (EAs) 

EAs are federally licensed tax practitioners who specialize in taxation and have unlimited rights to represent taxpayers before the IRS. While they may not provide the full range of services that CPAs do, they're excellent resources for tax-specific needs.

Bookkeepers 

Bookkeepers handle day-to-day financial transactions and record-keeping. While they may not provide tax or advisory services, they're essential for maintaining accurate financial records and can be more cost-effective for basic accounting needs.

2. Define Your Needs

Before beginning your search, take time to understand exactly what services you need. This step is crucial as it will help you narrow down the type of accounting professional that best suits your situation.

For Small Businesses: Consider whether you need comprehensive services including:

  • Daily bookkeeping and financial record maintenance
  • Payroll processing and tax filing
  • Monthly financial statement preparation
  • Tax planning and preparation
  • Business advisory services
  • Cash flow management
  • Budget development and monitoring
  • Financial projections and modeling

For Individuals: Your needs might include:

  • Personal tax return preparation
  • Estate planning
  • Retirement planning
  • Investment advice
  • Real estate transaction guidance
  • Inheritance tax planning
  • Personal financial planning
  • Tax strategy for self-employed individuals

Consider your current needs and potential future requirements. Are you looking for someone to handle just your annual tax returns, or do you need ongoing financial guidance? Will you need help with business expansion, retirement planning, or estate planning in the future? Understanding your needs will help you find an accountant with the right expertise.

3. Essential Qualifications to Look For

When evaluating potential accountants, several key qualifications should be at the top of your list:

Professional Credentials and Licensing 

Look for certified public accountants (CPAs) who are licensed in your state. While not all accounting tasks require a CPA, having one gives you access to the highest level of accounting expertise. Verify that they maintain active licenses and good standing with state boards. You can typically verify this information through your state's board of accountancy website.

Experience and Expertise 

Seek accountants with experience in your specific industry or situation. For businesses, industry expertise can be invaluable as different sectors have unique accounting requirements and tax considerations. For example, a construction company might need an accountant familiar with percentage of completion accounting, while a retailer needs someone experienced with inventory management and sales tax compliance.

Technology Adoption and Security Measures 

Modern accounting relies heavily on technology. Your accountant should be proficient with current accounting software and willing to work with your preferred systems. This expertise ensures efficient service and better accessibility to your financial information. Additionally, inquire about their cybersecurity measures to protect your sensitive financial data.

Industry Understanding 

Different industries have unique accounting challenges and regulatory requirements. An accountant with experience in your industry will be familiar with:

  • Industry-specific tax deductions and credits
  • Common financial challenges and solutions
  • Relevant regulatory requirements
  • Industry benchmarks and performance metrics
  • Specialized accounting methods particular to your field

4. Key Questions to Ask When Interviewing

When meeting with potential accountants, ask these essential questions:

About Their Practice

  • "What is your experience with clients similar to me?"
  • "How many clients do you serve in my industry/situation?"
  • "What is your approach to client communication?"
  • "Who will be my primary point of contact?"
  • "What is your response time for questions or concerns?"

About Services and Fees

  • "What specific services are included in your basic package?"
  • "What additional services might I need, and what do they cost?"
  • "How do you structure your fees? (Hourly, flat rate, retainer?)"
  • "Are there any additional charges I should be aware of?"
  • "How do you handle tax planning throughout the year?"

About Their Approach

  • "How do you help clients minimize their tax burden legally?"
  • "What is your philosophy on aggressive vs. conservative tax positions?"
  • "How do you stay current with changing tax laws and regulations?"
  • "What technology do you use, and how will it integrate with my systems?"

5. Red Flags to Watch For

Stay alert for these warning signs during your search:

Questionable Practices

  • Promising specific tax refund amounts before reviewing your documentation
  • Suggesting aggressive tax positions that seem too good to be true
  • Reluctance to sign tax returns as a paid preparer
  • Unwillingness to provide their PTIN (Preparer Tax Identification Number)

Communication Issues

  • Poor responsiveness during the initial consultation phase
  • Unclear or evasive answers about their experience or procedures
  • Unwillingness to explain their processes in terms you can understand
  • Resistance to providing references from current clients

Professional Concerns

  • Lack of professional liability insurance
  • Unclear or inconsistent fee structures
  • Unwillingness to provide engagement letters outlining services and fees
  • No clear process for handling sensitive documents securely

6. Making the Final Decision

Once you've interviewed potential accountants, consider these factors in your final decision:

Trust and Comfort Level 

Choose someone you feel comfortable discussing financial matters with and who explains things in terms you understand. This relationship often involves sharing sensitive information, so trust is paramount.

Value vs. Cost 

While cost is important, don't make it your only criterion. Consider:

  • The depth of services provided
  • The potential tax savings they can identify
  • The value of their advisory services
  • The peace of mind that comes with expert handling of your finances

Accessibility and Resources 

Ensure they have the staff and resources to handle your needs, especially during busy periods. Consider:

  • The size of their practice
  • Their client load
  • Support staff availability
  • Technology resources
  • Backup systems and procedures

Cultural Fit 

For businesses especially, consider how well the accountant's working style aligns with your company culture and values. Look for:

  • Similar communication styles
  • Shared values and ethics
  • Compatible working methods
  • Mutual understanding of goals and objectives

7. Taking the Next Step

After selecting your accountant, establish clear expectations from the start:

Initial Setup

  • Schedule a comprehensive initial meeting
  • Provide all relevant financial documentation
  • Discuss immediate priorities and concerns
  • Establish communication protocols
  • Set up access to necessary systems and information

Creating a Working Relationship

  • Define regular meeting schedules
  • Establish deadlines for providing information
  • Clarify roles and responsibilities
  • Set up regular financial review sessions
  • Create a tax planning calendar

Remember, this relationship is one of the most important professional partnerships you'll form. Take your time in the selection process, ask thorough questions, and trust your instincts. The right accountant will not only help manage your finances but will serve as a trusted advisor in your financial journey.

Looking for expert accounting services that prioritize honesty, transparency, and your financial well-being? Contact us today to learn how we can help you achieve your financial goals while keeping more of your hard-earned money in your pocket. Our team of experienced professionals is ready to provide the personalized attention and expertise you need to navigate your financial future successfully.